Since SummerSlam began in 1988, there have been 279 wrestlers to compete in matches on the pay-per-view event. We've ranked the Top 50.

 

How? It's all quite scientific, actually. Over a period of several weeks, we culled a database of every match that aired at the summer spectacular, who won, who lost and most importantly, who captured the gold. From there, we assigned scores for each competitor as follows:

 

  • 1 point per (wrestling) appearance

  • 10 points per win

  • 20 points for winning a championship

 

So, if, say, The Ultimate Warrior won the Intercontinental Championships at SummerSlam '88 (which he did), he would receive 31 points. But when his opponent, The Honky Tonk Man, lost the match, he only received 1 point. Got it?

 

Adding these points up over a period of 30+ years, Wrestling Merchandise and Memories compiled a list of the Top 50 SummerSlam Superstars. Oh, and a few other points to keep in mind:

 

  • To qualify, the match had to take place on the pay-per-view portion of the show. No dark matches, no kickoff show bouts and no free-for-alls.

  • These are only for wrestling matches; competitions such as "Diva Dodgeball" (SummerSlam 2004) wouldn't count.

 

If you'd like to be a part of this conversation, Tweet us at @canadianbulldog using the hashtag #Top50, or leave a comment below.


Ready? Here we go!

50.

Bertha Faye, Ronda Rousey, Chyna, Santino Marella (tie)

Bertha Faye, Ronda Rousey, WWE Hall of Famer Chyna and Santino Marella each scored 31 points. The first three accomplished this by winning the Womens Championship at SummerSlam, while Marella (a former Miss WrestleMania in his own right) won the Intercontinental Title.

48.

Tatanka, Sasha Banks, Jerry Lawler, Jim Neidhart (tie)

Tatanka, Sasha Banks and WWE Hall of Famers Jerry Lawler and Jim Neidhart each scored 33 points over three SummerSlam appearances. The King is undefeated at SummerSlam, with victories over Bret Hart, Jake Roberts and Tazz.

46.

Bray Wyatt

Bray Wyatt (a/k/a The Fiend) has 34 points over four SummerSlam appearances - oddly enough, the same score as his father in the previous entry! The Eater Of Worlds has wins over Kane, Chris Jericho and Finn Balor (however, he also lost to Balor in a 2017 match).

44.

Kevin Owens

Kevin Owens scored 35 points over five consecutive appearances at SummerSlam. The Prizefighter holds victories over Cesaro, the team of Enzo Amore and Big Cass (with partner Chris Jericho) and Shane McMahon, and has lost matches to Braun Strowman and AJ Styles.  

42.

Paige

Paige scored 42 points in just two SummerSlam appearances. In 2014, she captured the Divas Championship from AJ Lee and at the 2015 event, she teamed with Charlotte and Becky Lynch to defeat Nikki Bella, Brie Bella, Alicia Fox, Naomi, Tamina and Sasha Banks.

40.

Jeff Jarrett

WWE Hall of Famer Jeff Jarrett scored 43 points over the course of three SummerSlam matches. In 1994, he defeated Men on a Mission's Mabel. In 1998, Jarrett lost a match (and his hair) to X-Pac. And in 1999, Double J defeated D'Lo Brown to win both the WWF Intercontinental and European titles.

38.

Beth Phoenix

WWE Hall of Famer Beth Phoenix scored 43 points over the course of three SummerSlams. In 2007, she won an interpromotional battle royal over 11 women. In 2008, she captured the Women's Title in a mixed tag team match (with Santino Marella). And in 2011, she lost to Kelly Kelly.

36.

Alberto Del Rio

Alberto Del Rio scored 44 points through four SummerSlam matches. He competed twice in 2011, losing a six-man tag match and then defeating CM Punk for the World Title in a post-main event. In 2012, he lost to Sheamus, and in 2013, he defended the World Championship against Christian.

34.

Chris Benoit

Chris Benoit scored 45 points, competing in five SummerSlam matches. His biggest win was capturing the United States Championship from Orlando Jordan, while he also defeated Chris Jericho in a two out of three falls match. He lost matches to Randy Orton, Eddie Guerrero and Rob Van Dam.

32.

Rey Mysterio

Rey Mysterio scored 48 points, the result of competing at eight different SummerSlam events between 2002 and 2012. He defeated Eddie Guerrero, Dolph Ziggler and Chavo Guerrero, while losing to Chavo Guerrero, Kurt Angle and Kane.

30.

The Road Warriors

WWE Hall of Famers The Road Warriors (Animal and Hawk) each scored 53 points due to three SummerSlam appearances. In 1991, they defeated The Nasty Boys to win the WWF Tag Team Championship, and they also hold wins over Money Inc. and The Godwinns.

28.

Finn Balor

Finn Balor scored 54 points over four SummerSlam appearances. The Demon became the first Universal Champion by defeating Seth Rollins at SummerSlam 2016 and holds wins over Bray Wyatt and Baron Corbin.

26.

The Rock

The Rock scored 55 points at SummerSlam, having five matches. Among The Great One's victories, he defeated Billy Gunn in 1999, won a Triple Threat Match in 2000 and pinned Booker T to capture the WCW Title in 2001.

24.

Mick Foley

WWE Hall of Famer Mick Foley (a/k/a Mankind and Dude Love) scored 55 points at SummerSlam over five matches. He defeated Steve Austin and Triple H for the WWF Title in 1999, and has wins over The Undertaker in 1996 and HHH in 1997. 

20.

X-Pac

WWE Hall of Famer X-Pac (a/k/a The 1-2-3 Kid) has 56 points for five SummerSlam appearances. His biggest win was in 2001, when he unified the WWF and WCW Light Heavyweight/Cruiserweight Titles. He's also defeated  Jeff Jarrett and Road Dogg.

18.

Dolph Ziggler

Dolph Ziggler can "sow off" that he has scored 59 points over nine SummerSlam appearances. In 2014, Ziggler defeated The Miz to win the Intercontinental Title; he also holds two other victories. Ziggler's losses include Rey Mysterio, Chris Jericho, Dean Ambrose, Seth Rollins and Bill Goldberg.

16.

Rob Van Dam

Despite having only three SummerSlam matches to his credit, Rob Van Dam has amassed 63 points. In 2001, RVD defeated Jeff Hardy to win the Hardcore Championship; in 2002, he beat Chris Benoit to win the Intercontinental Title. The following year, Vam Dam dropped a No Holds Barred match to Kane.

14.

CM Punk

CM Punk scored 67 points over six SummerSlam appearances. He won the World Championship in 2009, defeated John Cena, John Bradshaw Layfield, and won a Triple Threat against Cena and The Big Show. Punk lost matches to John Morrison, Show, Alberto Del Rio (right after defeating Cena) and Brock Lesnar. 

12.

The Big Show

The Big Show scored 67 points, appearing at seven SummerSlam events over a 17-year period. In 1999, he and The Undertaker won the WWF Tag Team Championship from X-Pac and Kane. Show also holds wins over Sabu, Cryme Tyme (with partner Chris Jericho) and against the entire Straight Edge Society.

10.

Charlotte Flair

Charlotte Flair cracks the top 10 of this list scoring 84 points and is undefeated over four SummerSlam appearances. She captured championship gold in two of those matches (defeating Sasha Banks, Carmella and Becky Lynch); won a three-team elimination match; and defeated Trish Stratus.

8.

The Ultimate Warrior

WWE Hall of Famer The Ultimate Warrior is undefeated at SummerSlam with 95 points, winning five consecutive events between 1988 and 1992. He twice won the Intercontinental Title (defeating The Honky Tonk Man and Rick Rude) and also has wins over Randy Savage and a team led by Sgt. Slaughter.

6.

Brock Lesnar

Brock Lesnar scored 110 points over seven SummerSlam appearances. In two of those matches, he captured the WWE Championship, over The Rock in 2002 and John Cena in 2014. The Beast Incarnate also defeated CM Punk in 2013 and Randy Orton in 2016, while suffering losses to Kurt Angle and The Undertaker.

4.

Seth Rollins

Seth Rollins has made the most impressive jump on this list since we began compiling it, scoring 136 points in just six SummerSlam appearances. In three of those instances, he has gained championship gold, and holds victories over the likes of John Cena and Brock Lesnar.

2.

Randy Orton

Randy Orton scored 143 points, the result of 12 SummerSlam appearances between 2003 and 2019. Three times, Orton captured the WWE or World Championship, from Chris Benoit, Christian and Daniel Bryan. Orton has lost to Hulk Hogan, Roman Reigns, Kofi Kingston, an Elimination Chamber Match, and to Brock Lesnar

49

Al Snow, Melina, Steve Blackman, Virgil, Road Dogg (tie)

Al Snow, Melina, Steve Blackman, Virgil and WWE Hall of Famer Road Dogg each scored 32 points in our study. Notably, Wrestling Superstar Virgil won the Million Dollar Championship at SummerSlam 1991.

47.

Irwin R. Shyster

You tax cheats need to know that Irwin R. Shyster scored 34 points with four matches at SummerSlam. In 1991, IRS got the better of Greg The Hammer Valentine; in 1992, he and Ted DiBiase lost to The Legion Of Doom; In 1993 he defeated 123 Kid; and in 1994 he and Bam Bam Bigelow beat The Headshrinkers.

45

AJ Styles

AJ Styles has scored 34 points in our study, the result of four consecutive SummerSlam appearances. The Phenomenal One holds victories over John Cena, Kevin Owens and Ricochet at SummerSlam, and has a loss to Samoa Joe on his record. 

43.

The Texas Torando

WWE Hall of Famer The Texas Tornado (a/k/a Kerry Von Erich) scored 42 points, despite only two appearances at SummerSlam. His first outing in 1990 was as a substitute against Mr. Perfect, capturing the Intercontinental Title. The next year, Tornado teamed up with Davey Boy Smith and Ricky Steamboat.

41.

Razor Ramon

WWE Hall of Famer Razor Ramon scored 43 points through three SummerSlam appearances. In 1993, he defeated The Million Dollar Man Ted DiBiase. In 1994, he regained the Intercontinental Title over Diesel. And in 1995, The Bad Guy was defeated by Shawn Michaels in their famous ladder rematch.

39.

Big E

Big E scored 43 points over the course of three SummerSlam appearances, always in tag team action. In addition to tagging with Kaitlyn in 2013, Big E captured the WWE Tag Team Championship with Kofi Kingston in 2015 and successfully defended the SmackDown Tag Team Championship along with Xavier Woods in 2018.

37.

Natalya

Natalya scored 44 points in four SummerSlam appearances. She lost a Women's Battle Royal in 2007; won a six-woman tag team in 2016; defeated Naomi in 2017 to capture the SmackDown Womens Title; and lost to Raw Womens Champion Becky Lynch in 2019.

35

Stone Cold Steve Austin

WWE Hall of Famer Stone Cold Steve Austin scored 44 points over four matches at SummerSlam. He captured the Intercontinental Title from Owen Hart in 1997; defeated The Undertaker in the main event of 1998's event;  lost the WWF Title to Mankind in 1999; and lost to Kurt Angle by disqualification at the 2001 event.

33.

Batista

Batista scored 45 points, spread out over five SummerSlam matches. For three straight years, The Animal was in World Title matches, defending against JBL and winning by DQ against Great Khali and King Booker. He also defeated John Cena in 2008 and lost a Triple Threat match in 2004 to Edge.

29.

Billy Gunn

WWE Hall of Famer Billy Gunn has 54 points over four SummerSlams, both as a Smoking Gunn and a New Age Outlaw. The highlight came in 1998, when he and Road Dogg defeated Mankind to win the WWF Tag Team Titles. He was also successful in tag team matches in 1993 and 1995, and lost to The Rock in 1999.

27.

Dean Ambrose

Dean Ambrose scored 54 points over four SummerSlams. He holds victories over The Wyatt Family (with Roman Reigns) and The Bar (with Seth Rollins) as well as a singles victory over Dolph Ziggler. The Lunatic Fringe's sole SummerSlam loss was to former teammate Rollins.

25.

Roman Reigns

Roman Reigns scored 55 points, the result of five consecutive SummerSlam appearances. In 2018, The Big Dog defeated Brock Lesnar to win the Universal Championship and also holds wins over Randy Orton and (with partner Dean Ambrose) the duo of Harper and Rowan.

23.

Davey Boy Smith

Davey Boy Smith (a/k/a The British Bulldog - no relation) scored 55 points. He won the Intercontinental Title at SummerSlam 1992 and won a tag team match and a bout against Ken Shamrock. Conversely, Smith went to a time-limit draw at SummerSlam with The Rougeau Brothers and lost to Sycho Sid.

21.

Kurt Angle

WWE Hall of Famer Kurt Angle scored 56 points over six consecutive SummerSlam appearances. The Olympic Gold Medalist's sole loss in that time came at the hands of The Rock in 2000. However, Angle holds wins over Stone Cold Steve Austin, Rey Mysterio, Brock Lesnar, Eddie Guerrero and Eugene.

19.

Daniel Bryan

Daniel Bryan scored 56 points over five appearances. Highlights include defeating John Cena in 2013 to win the WWE Championship (and then losing it right away to a newly heeled Randy Orton), defeating Kane and being part of Team WWE when they were against Team Nexus.

17.

Chris Jericho

Guess what? Chris Jericho just made The List (well, this list), thanks to 61 points through 11 SummerSlam appearances. Y2J has defeated Rhyno, Cryme Tyme, The Nexus, Dolph Ziggler and Enzo & Cass. He's also lost matches to Chris Benoit, Ric Flair, Triple H, Edge, John Cena and Bray Wyatt.

15.

Hulk Hogan

WWE Hall of Famer Hulk Hogan has 66 points and is undefeated over six matches at SummerSlam. The Hulkster has wins over the teams of Ted DiBiase & Andre The Giant; Randy Savage & Zeus; Sgt. Slaughter, Col. Mustafa & Gen. Adnan; Earthquake, Shawn Michaels and Randy Orton.

13.

Kofi Kingston

Kofi Kingston has scored 67 points over seven SummerSlam appearances. He captured the WWE Tag Team Championship in 2015, and won various tag team matches in 2011 and 2012. Kofi also had tag team losses in 2008 and 2016 tag team matches, and no-contests in both 2010 and 2019.

11.

Shawn Michaels

WWE Hall of Famer Shawn Michaels is not only Mr. WrestleMania, but he's a contender for Mr. SummerSlam as well, scoring 71 points over 11 career SummerSlam appearances. The Heartbreak Kid's victories were over Mr. Perfect, Razor Ramon, Vader, Triple H and the team of Vince & Shane McMahon.

9.

Kane

Kane (a/k/a Isaac Yankem DDS) scored 91 points over 11 SummerSlam appearances between 1995 and 2013. Most notably, he and The Undertaker unified the WWF and WCW Tag Team Titles in 2001. The Big Red Machine also holds victories over Rob Van Dam, Matt Hardy, Finlay and The Great Khali.

7.

Triple H

WWE Hall of Famer Triple H scored 102 points, boosted by 12 appearances at SummerSlam from 1995 to 2012. In 1998, The Game defeated The Rock to win the Intercontinental Title, and in 2003 he won the Elimination Chamber. HHH also has wins over Bob Holly, Eugene, The McMahons, Great Khali and Legacy.

5.

Edge

WWE Hall of Famer Edge scored 130 points via 10 SummerSlam appearances. In 2000, he and Christian won the WWF Tag Team Titles and in 2001, he captured the Intercontinental Championship. Edge has wins over the likes of Chris Jericho & Batista, Eddie Guerrero, Matt Hardy and even John Cena.

3.

Bret Hart

WWE Hall of Famer Bret Hart scored 141 points, appearing in 11 SummerSlam matches between 1988 and 2010. He captured the WWF Tag Team Titles from Demolition in 1990, the Intercontinental Championship from Mr. Perfect in 1991, and in 1997, The Hit Man defeated The Undertaker to win the WWF Title.

1.

The Undertaker

Although The Undertaker is synonymous with his work at WrestleMania, he also has 16 matches at SummerSlam under his part, scoring 156 points in total. The Dead Man has six losses to his name, but also captured tag team gold in 1999 (with The Big Show) and 2001 (with Kane). Victories include Kamala, Giant Gonzales, Fake Undertaker, Kama, Test, Albert and Brock Lesnar.

Learn More About Canadian Bulldog

  • Email
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Email
Grappling Gamer logo.jpg
Wrestling Merchandise and Memories podca
Wrestling Historian Mike Rickard